Supreme Court strikes down Bihar rules requiring mutation certificates for property registration, ruling they are ultra vires the Registration Act and violate constitutional right to freely dispose of property.
Can the Bihar government make mutation certificates (jamabandi/holding allotment) mandatory for property registration, effectively stopping property sales if owners can't produce these documents?
No, this is unconstitutional and beyond legal authority.
The Supreme Court has struck down the 2019 Bihar Registration Rules amendment that made mutation certificates mandatory for property registration because:
The court quashed the impugned sub-rules 19(xvii) and 19(xviii) of Bihar Registration Rules, restoring citizens' freedom to register property documents without mutation certificates.
Registration Act Enacted: Establishes India's presumptive titling system - registers documents, not titles
Bihar Land Laws: Bihar Land Mutation Act and Bihar Special Survey and Settlement Act passed but implementation remains incomplete
Controversial Amendment: Bihar introduces sub-rules 19(xvii) and (xviii) making mutation certificates mandatory for property registration
Legal Challenges: Multiple writ petitions filed in Patna High Court challenging the amendment's validity
High Court Judgment: Patna High Court dismisses petitions, upholds amendment despite acknowledging rule-making power issues
Supreme Court Victory: Strikes down amendment as ultra vires and unconstitutional, protects property rights
| Situation | Your Rights | Immediate Action |
|---|---|---|
| Registration refused for missing jamabandi | Illegal refusal - mutation not mandatory after Supreme Court judgment | Show copy of judgment, demand registration citing Section 52 of Registration Act |
| Authority insists on mutation certificate | Beyond legal authority - rules struck down as ultra vires | File written complaint to Inspector General of Registration |
| Continuous refusal despite judgment | Violation of constitutional property rights | File contempt petition or writ petition in High Court |
| Property documents complete but no mutation | Full right to register - mutation separate from registration | Proceed with registration, handle mutation separately later |
Latin for "beyond powers" - when an authority acts beyond the legal power granted to it. The rules were ultra vires the Registration Act.
Revenue record entry in Bihar showing person responsible for paying land revenue. Not proof of ownership, only for revenue purposes.
India's current system where registration creates presumption of ownership that can be challenged in court, unlike conclusive titling.
Process of updating revenue records when property ownership changes. Separate from registration and doesn't confer title.
"The time has come to move towards a system in which the sale and purchase of immovable property becomes simpler, and registration serves as a conclusive proof of ownership guaranteed by the State... We have explored this possibility and found promise in emerging technologies such as Blockchain."
"The constitutionally protected right to own immovable property inherently includes the freedom to freely acquire, possess and dispose it at will... A requirement of rules, regulations or even law that impedes or restrains easy and effective transfer of property will be illegal as it has the direct effect of 'depriving of property' to that extent."
This landmark judgment reaffirms that property rights are fundamental and cannot be arbitrarily restricted through subordinate legislation. It protects citizens from bureaucratic overreach while acknowledging the need for modern, technology-driven property registration systems.
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified legal professional for specific legal guidance. The information provided is based on judicial interpretation and may be subject to changes in law.
Making Supreme Court judgments accessible and actionable for every Indian citizen navigating legal challenges.
This analysis decodes a complex constitutional property rights judgment to help citizens understand their rights in property registration and protection against arbitrary bureaucratic restrictions.